A former reality TV personality from Ohio is facing serious criminal charges after his recent arrest. Tony McCollister, who once appeared on the A&E reality show Neighbors with Benefits, was taken into custody on December 23, 2025. The show, which focused on couples involved in a swinger lifestyle, aired briefly in 2015 before being canceled due to public criticism.
Reality TV Star Arrested on Sex Crime Charges
According to local reports, Tony McCollister has been charged with very serious offenses, including pandering obscenity involving a minor and sexual conduct with an animal. Court records claim that he knowingly uploaded illegal material involving a child to an online account. Authorities also allege that he was involved in sexual acts with animals he owned. Investigators say these alleged crimes took place in late November.
Melissa Gilbert Has “Little House on the Prairie” Reunion with On-Screen Sister Melissa Sue Anderson
Tony McCollister is 43 years old and lived at a home near South Lebanon, Ohio. The property is reportedly owned by a woman named Erica Grove. Court documents state that Grove is also facing a misdemeanor charge related to sexual conduct with an animal. She did not appear on the reality show, and officials have not shared details about her relationship with McCollister. She was served a court summons and is expected to appear in court soon.
Under Ohio law, sexual conduct with an animal is considered a misdemeanor, while pandering obscenity involving a minor is a felony. If McCollister is found guilty of the felony charge, he could face up to eight years in prison and a fine of up to $15,000. A judge has set his bond at $250,000 and ordered that he have no contact with children or animals while the case continues.
Follow for more Updates. Join Our Telegram Channel
Tony McCollister next court appearance is scheduled for December 30. His arrest has brought renewed attention to the canceled reality show, which was pulled off the air after just two episodes. Authorities continue to investigate the case, and no further details have been released at this time. Officials remind the public that anyone who suspects child abuse should report it to proper authorities so action can be taken quickly.
Author: Purnima s
Purnima | Entertainment Blogger 4+ yrs writing fun blogs on movies, celebs & trends. Pop culture addict serving fresh, binge-worthy content!
